I understand the finish should be natural which I assume is phospate and oil. I refinished the ones for my 71 with manganese phosphate and they look darker than what I see in photos of other cars.
Guessing these "other cars" are restored ones
Should they be dark, light or anywhere in between?
Hard to tell with out seeing what you ended up with since every batch can be different and Mag base Phosphate can come out very dark. Have seen plenty of redone ones in zinc phosphate that were too light IMHO
My description would be a medium tot medium dark is what I look for.
Will take some pictures of ones I just did on my 71 if I can find my camera