I got the Scott Drake rear seat divider C7ZZ-6545728 from CJ Pony Parts.
Here are my thoughts compared to what came out of the car.
1. Wrong color The one in the car was almost black this one is a very light gray.
2. Quite a bit thinner. The original was thick.
3. Some minor stamping diffrence
On closer examination I dont think mine is that bad so I am going to try to fix it. I think I will glue some fabric to the back side of the rips to kind of hold it together. The missing material at the bottom I think will be hidden. Here are some pictures of the damage: