So, not to beat a dead horse... but before I posted the original question here, I emailed VA Classic Mustangs about their underlayment. Their website says "Material is made by an OEM supplier in Michigan to original standards. It features a durable asphalt layer with a soft needled cotton backing just like the oriignal material used in the 1960s and '70s". When I asked about the foil, they said "The originals did not have any foil in them" and "our ST841 underlayments are made like the original".
So, is mine really original, or is VA Classic wrong? If mine is original, I will, as suggested, make a replica. I'd rather not replicate something that isn't even original.
Thanks... and sorry for the dead horse.