The replacement rotor is the one piece looking affair. Your pic 2 & 4.
I believe the 68 rotors are similar to 67s with a few differences.
The 68 original assembly rotors have a square cutout in the hub face along with a drilled hole like 67. Rather than having windows in the rotor portion like 67, the windows are gone and are solid. Also, the thickness and throwaway dimension is different between the two.
Here are a few pics of what I'm told are original 68 assembly line rotors.