Jeff,
Thanks for the Amazon idea. I'm going with "3 inch x 60 Yard 55 Meter Black Gaffers Tape No Residue Cloth Matte Finish Rubber Adhesive" from Amazon. Yes, I have an original piece right in front of me so I know what I'm looking for. Trimming it from 3" to 2 7/8" wide should be easy. As you say, finding the right finish is the tricky part. I've got a 51 year old piece of tape (that has seen better days), I'm trying to match with pictures on a monitor. I'll report back when the new roll arrives.
Thanks everybody for the feedback. Hope to see many of you at the Houston MCA show next month.
Mike
68 coupe, Dearborn plant.