Now that this thread is "resurrected" again, I'll report on what I found on my '67 a couple weeks ago when we went to our Colorado place where the '67 resides. My, "believed to be original" Headlight Trim screws were exactly like Marty's - No. 8-18, Flat Head, Phillips, Blunt Tip, SST Trim (No. 6 Head) screws, 7/8" to 1" long.
Doing some basic research, the screw you want has a Ford part number of 374798-S. It is a 8-18X1.0 oval, .257-.279 dia, head, stainless steel, Phillips drive, screw. If you look at the AMK Guide to Ford Fasteners, page 154, you will see that screw listed. Right under it is Ford part number 376364-S which has the same exact specifications. It is used on 1969 Mustangs but with a -S102 finish (rear window trim as a black screw). However, 376364-S is sold by AMK products as their stock number B-11120, 10 pieces - $3 as a stainless screw, no mention of black color (they also offer it a chrome plated stainless). An inquiry at AMK as to what actual finish might be beneficial.
Jim
Now this is interesting Jim; my AMK Guide to Ford Fasteners shows Part # 374398-S on Page 147, and is described exactly as I noted above, except the length is shown as 1.00".
In the attached excerpt, % stands for "Trim Head", and the # stands for SST.
Based on others' comments (Marty and Dave) as well as on mine, I believe the correct screw should be the Flat Head, not the Oval Head. I have attached a few pictures of what this screw looks like.
To carry this a little further, I have checked about a dozen of some of my "Go To" Hardware sources, and could not find a Flat Head, Phillips, No. 8 Body. No. 6 Head, Blunt Tipped, SST screw. A No. 8 screw has too big of a Head for the countersinks in the Headlight Trim Ring. A No. 6 of course fits the countersinks, but its body is too small for the existing Nylon "Nuts". The solution is to use the No. 6 screws (which I have found exact except I have only fount them 3/4" long), and new Nylon Nuts which are for No. 6 screws, and push in to a 1/4" square hole in the front fender extension. Thank goodness my originals are all accounted for.
Bob