Well, I spoke with Bill @ Bill Herndon's Ponywarehouse concerning the NOS rocker panel moldings I purchased from him. I believe his position is that the damaged moldings had never been out of the plastic wrappers, therefore the problem is Ford's, not his. While I'm pretty irritated about this, I am able to see his perspective on the situation.
That said, I'm not completely convinced the moldings I bought from him truly came from Ford sealed in *that* specific plastic packaging. I'll admit I am no expert at NOS parts, but having spent the past 15 years locating and buying NOS parts, these plastic bags that held the moldings don't look like Ford packaging I'm accustomed to seeing. There was simply a modern-looking white sticker affixed to each plastic bag with the ford PN on it. The front clip (at the fender) which was attached to each molding, however, does have a ford PN molded into it.
Anyway, so now I know I spent big bucks on a pair of cosmetically flawed "NOS" rocker moldings and I'm stuck with them. Super. But, I guess it's time to quit crying in my soup and move on to a solution. Since I'm not able to locate another NOS pair, I will give McNichols Anodizing a call and see where we go from here. Thanks for the tip on the source for anodizing!