Consider, that like many NOS parts, these service replacements could and often were made much later, by different suppliers (than original) and often looked very different from assembly line pieces.
NOS, in every case, is not always a good IMHO source for concours parts for restorations. Each should be evaluated on its own merits
Have never seen the one you show with the thin outer edge on an original car nor have removed a similar one from a car over the years.