Mine were originals and they had the hard sealer. I had some that I got for the reflectors that had the soft glazing putty. I am certain they are not the same. I bought some replacements on eBay and they were beautiful but not close to correct. I'll post some pictures the first will be the ones that came off the car. The LH one is the replacement and the RH is the one that I restored. No England on the glass or body of the replacement and they have the wrong wire grommet and rivets.
Marty