I figured it out. Two wires were reversed on the switch, which was how the thing was connected when it came into my possession.
The resistance is built into the motor and an external resistor is not used like 65 or the heater blower motor.
For posterity, after breaking the motor down I recorded:
2.8 ohms for red wire
2 ohms for yellow wire
1.4 ohms for orange wire
So when connecting to the switch, the red wire goes on the terminal that is only active in switch position one, the yellow wire goes to the terminal that is only active in switch position two, and the orange wire goes to the terminal that is only active in switch position three. The terminal that is active in all three switch positions is the wire to the thermostatic switch. The other terminal position on the switch is the power input.
There is nothing inside the switch except for a spring keeping a copper disc pressed against the terminals, when the switch is rotated, the disc rotates making the appropriate connections.
I should have tried harder before posting...but that is what I get for assuming it was wired correctly to start with. At least everything works.