My name is Chris. I'm Jim's neighbor. I am very familiar with 3d printers, although I do not scan things. I will forward Jim a YouTube video of a guys scanning objects then printing them.
You can also download a program called Fusion 360 but it does not scan. it is a CAD program where you can make your item manually and probably get much better results. they offer a free version through Autodesk for hobbyists.
Thanks,
Chris