I have several console trim plates and all have the aluminum strip that Jeff talked about. I picked the "best" and used it on my console. If you need the strips (long panel, shifter, ash tray and door) you can find them on e-bay under "66 Ford Mustang console". I've tried to salvage a couple and it's difficult, they bend and don't sit flat. As to the color match, you might just want to bite the bullet and get a complete new set and do everything. At least then you will have a match.
Jim