Well this afternoon I went through all my reamers and found I do not have one of the appropriate size to work for this. I tried a set of LufKin snap gages to get an accurate inside diameter for the pulley but that was unsuccessful, the number was smaller than the shaft by an amount that was inconceivable (think .005").
With my Brown and Sharpe 579-1 dial caliper the ID measuring side has knife edges so that is probably more accurate, but not accurate enough to make one. It measured the PS pulley ID at .685" - this is an original 6AA pulley in very nice condition.
The shaft OD measures .686" with the same tool. My guess is that the actual fit is more like a difference of .0008" +/- .0001" but I do not have the means to measure to four decimal places.