So I am going to reopen this discussion, and ask more basic. This might be something of an opinion question. What is the correct clutch to start with? Lets go ahead with the assumption that the york compressor I have is correct. Did the York Compressor always use the doughnut type filed or could it also have the the brush type? The MPC Lists both types as possible on a 351 but does not specify a specify a specific compressor to clutch application. The unrestored example pictures I dont think are conclusive as there is strong evidence (to me, tag/wiring clip used in 1970 is gone, compressor cereal plate is gone accept for 1, but that one is an unpainted compressor and I have not seen any other 1970 or earlier originals unpainted ) they have been altered from the factory.
Additional research seems to be that after 1970 only the type 5 "doughnut" field was used and it seems that the type 5 was the most common "service replacement" type available. For sure that is what we see in most examples. However, I have now found a few examples or what are claimed to be original 1970 compressors that are the York type and have the type 3 "brush" clutch. Thoughts?