While an "Aftermarket" part can always carry along with it as not being exactly like the original, I think a more likely difference in this case is a change that was made by Ford. I have attached a page from the 1960-68 Ford Master Parts Catalog that shows Push Rods for 390's. Note that prior to 01/15/68, it shows the Push Rod as Part # C4TZ-6565-B, at 9.62" long, and to be used with Tappet (Lifter) C3DZ-6500-B (a carryover from previous 352's) ; for "from 01.15/68", it shows the Push Rod as Part # C8AZ-6565-A, at 9.59" long, to be used with Tappet C8AZ-6500-A. In addition, to confuse matters further, note that several "oversize" (OS), and "undersize" (US) length push rods were added as new parts (in case you are interested, the circle with the line through it "Indicates changes and additions such as change in model application, dimension, etc." and the "ยง" symbol "Indicates part number being added").
Just a good possibility of what you have encountered.
Bob